A website that goes under the name The Love Tank has recently come under scrutiny, after it was revealed that it had received lottery funding to help its campaign advising gender dysphoric children on how to get puberty blockers – now banned under UK law because of their potential harm The website also carries extensive advice on queer, transgender, and non-binary sexual behaviours and health issues, working with various London-based authorities to implement, what it calls, its ‘programme for change’.
They are not unique. There are many such groups fighting to achieve, what they call, LGBT equality and integration, and over the past few decades they have been quite astonishingly successful. Almost every programme on television these days, for instance, includes gay characters and rainbow families, while politicians, who would once have kept their sexuality secret, now openly celebrate their same-sex weddings. Yet, despite these inroads, LGB and trans activists, with everything in between, still insist that they are being subjected to coercive and cruel conversion practices.
What does this mean exactly? Are gay, transgender and non-binary people being forced into having electro-convulsive shock treatment, aversion therapy, lobotomy … the administration of mind-altering drugs? And who are the people doing these terrible things to them?
Turns out, the reality is not quite so lurid as campaigners would have us believe. Electro-convulsive treatment and aversion therapy were both rightly abandoned around 60 years ago and are now illegal, as are all coercive treatments. And, while homosexuality is prohibited to both Christians and Muslims, it’s no longer classified as a mental illness, and there are no mandated treatments for medical intervention aimed at ‘curing’ them at all, while, as seen above, there is now widespread public acceptance. In fact, a helpline set up four years ago to help victims of conversion therapy, which at the time estimated some 15,000 calls a year, has had to revise its estimate down to around 300 – less than one call a day in any given year. Which would seem to indicate (a) that the numbers were massively over-hyped and (b) that the ‘problem’ is actually somewhere between minimal and non-existent.
So accusations of coercion and cruelty would appear to be aimed, not so much at treatment or attempts at forced conversion, as at attitudes that imply criticism. In which regard, the Church appears especially singled out for blame, with the Bible’s clear prohibition against homosexuality labelled hatred, bigotry, and intolerance.
Notwithstanding, Andy Burnham has seen fit to give his full support to the draft Conversion Practices Bill, now before Parliament. Specifically, this Bill seeks to ban any practices intended to change or suppress an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity, making it an offence punishable by 5 years imprisonment to cause harm to an individual’s physical or mental health, or to cause alarm or distress that may have adverse effects on a person’s day to day life.
Note, there doesn’t have to be any evidence of actual harm. All that is needed is for someone to say that they felt alarmed or distressed. Which of course means that anything that might be remotely construed as criticism – no matter how well-intentioned – could, under the terms of the Bill, be criminalised.
For example, prayer offered by a minister of religion to someone in distress, which did not affirm LGBT behaviour, would be an offence. Passages quoted from the Bible condemning homosexuality, or even affirming God’s creation of (only) two sexes, would also be an offence. Similarly, a doctor who refused to prescribe puberty blockers or to refer a child for gender reassignment … might be committing an offence. While parents, urging their gender dysphoric child to wait, might not only find themselves charged with a crime, but would in all likelihood be reported to social services for abuse and have their child taken into care.
Alarmingly, it has been revealed that, in drawing up the Bill, the government has relied on advice from the trans-activist group Stonewall, even going so far as to invite the group’s head of policy to a meeting in Downing Street. Similar access was notably not offered to gender-critical groups, and nor did the government invite evidence from gender detransitioners, such as Charlie Evans, who have been loud in their condemnation of what they now label medical harm.
So what is going on here? Why are LGBTQ groups seemingly free to push so distorted a narrative, while those who disagree find themselves increasingly marginalised and silenced?
The Encyclopaedia Britannica defines ideology as, ‘a form of social or political philosophy, or a system of ideas, that aspires both to explain the world and to change it’ (emphasis added). This is surely what Andy Burnham and LGBTQ+ activists are attempting to do – to change the values governing society. The medical risks attaching to homosexuality are well documented – syphilis, gonorrhoea, AIDS, higher rates of mental illness, etc, etc … All have far higher rates within the LGBTQ community than for the rest of the population. Similarly well documented are the harms to children resulting from gender transition, as laid out in the Cass Report, which specifically highlights the dangers of puberty blockers. Contrary to claims that these drugs do no harm and can be easily reversed, providing relief to a gender dysphoric child awaiting reassignment, Cass warned of possible irreversible disruption to normal brain development, bone density impairment, and adverse long-term effects on fertility. Small wonder parents may feel concerned at their child’s expressed wish to change gender! And small wonder that they should urge caution – especially in light of the ever-increasing number of transition regretters, who say their bodies have been mutilated.
If this Bill goes through, these are the facts and stories we will not be allowed to hear. These are the victims society will not be allowed to help – because LGBTQ activists would deny their existence.
The main aim of this pernicious Bill is not to help distressed and victimised members of the LGBTQ community, but to stifle freedom of expression and dissent. It is a tool for repression, enabling the reconfiguration and totalitarian control of a society being progressively cowed into submission. It is deception dressed up as care.
In his Gettysburg address, Abraham Lincoln famously said, ‘Government of the people, by the people, for the people’. The attempt by ideologues to impose their distorted view onto the rest of society and take control must be resisted.
Lynda Rose, Voice for Justice, is a reader-supported publication.
To receive new posts and support Lynda’s work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.