The Government is seeking to extend the powers of the Charity Commission to tackle what it calls ‘extremism’, and is holding a Consultation to which members of the public are invited to respond. It closes on Wednesday, 23rd December at 5 p.m.
Excellent, you may think. It’s about time there was a crackdown on what feels to be the ever-increasing discrimination against Christians. But in our skewed world it would seem that the powers being proposed, far from defending the right of Christians to freedom of belief and free speech, may actually impose the reverse.
Let us be clear. To tackle genuine extremism is good. To brand belief in the Bible as extremism … is bad. Yet this is precisely what these new powers, if passed, could allow.
Under a section entitled, Promotion or encouragement of violence, or racial or religious hatred, the Government is proposing a new condition that will allow the Commission to disqualify from serving as trustees or senior management, ‘individuals who engage in conduct or express views which promote or encourage (or would be reasonably likely to promote or encourage) violence, or hatred against any group of people defined by reference to their race, or their religion or belief (as defined by the Equality Act 2010). This condition could apply to actions or views expressed against individuals, or groups of people, or organisations‘ (emphasis added).
And here, as they say, is the rub, because this catch-all provision could be applied to people such as pro-life campaigner Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, arrested for praying silently outside a closed abortion facility, when everyone had gone home. Her silent witness could well be construed as an expression of unvoiced judgment on individuals availing themselves of the clinic’s facilities, or of the abortion providers themselves. This could be designated a non-hate crime offence and, under the Charity Commission’s proposed new powers, Isabel could then find herself ‘disqualified’ (i.e. banned), from charitable pro-life work. And doubtless, someone who verbally expressed genuine concern over the spread of Sharia law, or Muslim treatment of women, might also find themselves caught by this proposed change to charity law, because their opinions, no matter how balanced and well-argued, could be interpreted not as justified comment, but as an expression of racial and religious hatred.
The problem of ‘extremism’ does of course need addressing. There is clearly an issue at the moment with some pro-Palestine and far-left groups, exploiting their charitable status to carry out activities with proscribed organisations and sending money to terrorist groups overseas. But that is a world away from Christians – attempting to live out their faith – who speak up to defend the right of the unborn to life, to defend traditional marriage as between one man and one woman for life, and who say that gender is determined by biological sex. Labelling hitherto mainstream Christian beliefs as extremist feels indeed to be part of the ever-increasing attack on Christianity and Christian values, simply designed to close down criticism, whether implied or overt – and no matter how well justified – of the new Weltanschauung.
Freedom of belief and freedom of speech, even where the views expressed provoke outrage and anger, are protected under UK law, so long as they do not incite hatred or violence. Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), as implemented by the Human Rights Act 1998, states that everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, and the right to manifest such beliefs in public. In similar vein, Article 10 says that everyone shall have the right to freedom of expression, including the right to express opinions that may shock or offend others; again, providing they do not incite violence or hatred.
The new proposed powers of the Charity Commission, however, could potentially overturn these rights, allowing those expressing ‘unpopular’ views to be summarily disqualified from charitable engagement.
To come at this from another angle, the proposed powers could be used to impose uniformity onto the charitable sector, shutting down charities that deviate from the ‘approved’ line. Such use would be an offence against democracy. Should this new power be allowed, it must be made clear that holding and manifesting Bible-based Christian beliefs are exempt. The nation’s democratic freedoms must be protected, and the ever-growing discrimination against Christians must end.
Read about the Consultation here:
https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/consultation-on-the-extension-of-the-charity-commissions-powers-to-tackle-extremism/consultation-on-the-extension-of-the-charity-commissions-powers-to-tackle-extremism
Please respond here:
https://dcms.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_1YPMIv2LHyzS6ZE
If you would like help, VfJUK will be posting guidance on how to respond on our website next week.